Topic started by Anbu. S (@ proxy.singnet.com.sg) on Fri May 1 07:19:56 EDT 1998.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
After the great Kaviarasu Kannadhasan, Vairamuthu is used to call as Kaviarasu Vairamuthu, is it acceptable by you, can u compare VM with KK...
- From: Ravi (@ envy.cs.umass.edu)
on: Fri May 1 09:20:17 EDT 1998
Anbu: ithai ErkanavE discuss seythu irukkirOm. Archives-il thEdi paarunga.
- From: Kumar Venkataraman (@ cache-eb-1.superlink.net)
on: Fri May 1 16:13:54 EDT 1998
can u compare VM with KK?
oh sure! these lines just got me carried away: (anbae anbae kollaadhae, jeans)
koduththu vaiththa poovae poovae aval koondhal manam solvaayaa?
koduththu vaiththa nadhiyae nadhiyae aval kuliththa sugam solvaayaa?
koduththu vaiththa kolusae kolusae kaalalavaich cholvaayaa?
koduththu vaiththa maniyae maniyae maarazhagaich cholvaayaa?
azhagai miga azhagaay varniththullaarae!
poo kitta koondhal manaththak kaekkanumaa?! yappoav! engayoa poaytteenga!
- From: NOV (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Fri May 1 20:46:21 EDT 1998
Anbu - Ravi is absolutely right. FYI, the Kaviarasu pattam is given by the State. Kannadhasan is no more, so they have to give the honour to someone.
For instance, MGR is no more, but someone has to govern Tamilnadu and that's why you have the likes of ........ :-))
Kumar - Yengey romba naalaa kaanum? :-))
Doesn't the poovae aval koondhal manam solvaayaa? take you back to the Thiruvilayadal days of Pothigaimalai uchchiyiley purappadum thendral? :-))
- From: Anban (@ pm3-fdl04-ppp-22.tcccom.net)
on: Fri May 1 23:19:18 EDT 1998
Intha Topic erkanave discuss seithu Diamond 'Kaapathunga'nnu kathara alavukku vanthathu.
Marupadiyuma?...It's ok..He deserved it..
Aval Koondhalil irunthathaal
poovum vaasam petrathu..
Aval kulithathal antha
nathiyum sugam petrathu..
Pennin kaalavin varayarai avalin
kolugalai vaithe mudivedukkappattathu..
Ponnalaghai neril partha aval
Kannadiyum vetkap pattathu..
'Ille parava illinga..enakku Kaviyarasu pattamellam vendam..avarukke kodunga..!!'.
Avarkalai avarkale virumpukirarkal..
Avarkalai avarkale prathibalikkirarkal..
Avarkalai avarkale perumai paduthikolkirarkal..
Avarkalai avarkale vimarsithum kolkirarkal..
Karanam...avarkalin thiramaigalai solla anku
yaarukkum thiramai illai!!.
Athanaalthaan..avarkale avarkalal Devarkal
Thamizh makkalukku puriyatha vishyam ethumillai..
Kalathin kattayam..kavignanai mattum viduma enna?
kaviyarasin kaviyai kalathal marakka mudiyaathathu
Kan pona pokkile kaal pogalama..?
Kaal pona pokkile manam pogalama..?
manam pona pokkile manithan pogalama..?
manithan pona paathayai maranthu pogalama..?
Veedu varai manaivi..
Veethi varai uravu..
Kaadu varai pillai..
Kadaisi varai yaro..
Ninaipathellam nadanthu vittal
Avar..avarukku nigar avare..Arthamulla Hindhu
mathathin thalaivan..arthamulla oru kavignan!!
- From: Kumar Venkataraman (@ cache-eb-1.superlink.net)
on: Fri May 1 23:40:30 EDT 1998
NOV, adha aen kaekkareenga (chumma therinjikkalaamaennudhaan!) En lyrics site-a maintain pannaradhukkulla poadhum poadhumnu aayidudhu. Poadhaakkoraikku, office-la vaera orae pidungal! FYI, I have indexed TFSA by songs too, for quicker searches.
Anban, your reply was cool.
Acc. to me, arasu (King) enru oruvarai mattum kurippida mudiyaadhu. AMF, chakkaravarththi (Emperor) enrum kooda oruvarai mattumae kurippittadhillai, sariththiraththil.
A poet is only as great as his critics want him to be. And VM's poems do titillate me.
- From: Ravi (@ envy.cs.umass.edu)
on: Sat May 2 11:24:13 EDT 1998
NOV: 'arasavai kavingar' thaan arasu aLippathu. 'kaviarasu' anabargaL aLippathu. vairamuththu thanakkE aLiththu kondathu. :-).
- From: anand (@ jester.ti.com)
on: Mon May 4 05:47:32 EDT 1998
kavichakravarthy - kamban
mahaakavi - bharathi
kaviarasu - kannadhasan
vairamuthu veru ethaiyavathu vaithukollattume. Innoruvar pattathai vaithukolvathen(?)
- From: Udhaya (@ host17.globalcenter.net)
on: Tue May 5 02:31:52 EDT 1998
Nanbargale, kavingargalin thiramaiyai oppiduvom, pattangal kidakkattum.
Vaanam Enukkoru Bodhi Maram
Naalum Enakkathu Sethi Tharum
ennum sokkavaikkum sorkalal arimugamanen Vairamuthuvidam.
Vaaliyai nambinal varudathirku oru nalla padam kidaithal perusu enru iruntha pothu, vairmutthuvin puthukavithai oru sila varutangalukku kannadasanin ezhappai anegamaga eedukattikondirunthathu
Aanal,Indru Vairamuthu oru formula kavingar aagivittar. (time for English) Ever since his rebirth under ARR, vairamuthu has only been writing songs of lists. Let me explain. Since chinna chinna aasai, which was a great hit and deservedly so, vairamuthu only compile lists of great attributes:
1)From Duet- a list of what is best in each category--kuliccha kutraalam,kumbitta paramasivam,etc.
2)From Puthiya Mugam-a list of what is good for what--kannukku mai azhagu, kavithaikku, etc.
3)From Minsara Kanavu-a list of what things one desires--poo pookum oasai athai ketkathan aasai, etc.
4)From Jeans-a list of all things that are wonders--Poovukkul olinthirukkum pani, etc.
5)From many movies-songs about lists of improbabilities:"Putham puthu boomi vendum, nitham oru vaanam vendum, thanga mazhai peya vendum", "MTVyil sashtikavasam nee padu, Disney landil vaasal thelichu arisi mavu kolam podu", etc.
Well, friends, you get the picture. Vairamuthu is an undoubtedly talented poet who may still have richness in him. But Vairamuthu is more a business man who knows how to recylce a selling formula successfully than a poet like Kannadasan who pours analogies and ironies like a wellspring. I have rarely heard Kannadasan use the same analogy twice. That is something Vairamuthu and Vaali and all the lesser poets can never claim.
- From: Amma (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Tue May 5 02:39:24 EDT 1998
on hearing VM's songs, i often wonder if tamil as a language is inadequate to express various sentiments that the songwriter has had to borrow usages from popular usage to 'eedukattufy' the shortcomings. Kannadasan was a great thinker. he had beautiful themes woven around a song. Idea was central to all his songs. One cannot but help notice how VM's songs are so word-driven while Kannadasan's were idea-specific. there must be little doubt who is superior. Kannadasanukku yen panivu kalanda vanakkangal.
- From: Amma (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Wed May 6 03:34:59 EDT 1998
Neenga oru paatai maranduttenga. List of all that can be taken easy from the movie 'Kaadalan'. No doubt Vairamuthu is writer who knows his market very well.
- From: Udhaya (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Wed May 6 13:16:55 EDT 1998
Thanks for the reminder Amma,
I'm sure there are even more if we dig through all the new stuff. But I just wanted to show a trend emerging. I'm surprised to see that you were the only one to respond to my message. I suppose, not too many people expect profound lyrics in songs these days. I believe that when we the people accept a lesser song, it paves the way for many more to enter the arena.
- From: badri raghavan (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Thu May 7 03:01:23 EDT 1998
sorkalin jaalamdhan kavidhai, illakiyam endru indha kaalathil oru ninaipu irrukiradhu. pattimandrangalil, kaviarangangalil ellam idhe trenddhan. idharku cinema'vum vilakalla.
One accusation that has been hurled at VM is that he has not written any (or many) thathuva paadalgal like Kannadasan. his retort that "it is a misnormer that only death is related to thathuvam. in my opinion love is also one, friendship is another ..." is also interesting.
I tend to subscribe to the view that all art is contemporary. it is not reasonable to expect a Sivaji or a TMS to emerge today and become a favourite. one should go with the times and i think VM is extremely saleable because of his ability to relate to the market needs. today's movies do not need songs like "veedu varai uravu" or "kan pona pokile". the trend is to have breezy songs with little or no lyrical value. let's accept this fact and not castigate VM for his lyrics. the crux lies in each one of us who patronise such themes and songs.
titles do not add value to a person if he has no intrinsic capabilities. i feel that there is an inate tendency to seek an identity in a title rather than add value to it. vairamuthu can never become a kannadasan and most importantly, does not have to become one. just by affixing a title that is normally associated with KD if somebody feels that he has scaled the peaks, then they are far from truth.
- From: Ramesh (@ interlock.itthartford.com)
on: Thu May 7 12:05:14 EDT 1998
Paramasivan Kazhuthilirundu Pambu Kettadu
Yarum Irukkum Idathil Irundu Kondal Ellan Sowkyime
Adhil Artham Ullandu...
I think it is very very unfair to compare two poets the one who is 'LEGENDARY' and the one who is 'SUPER STAR' . Kannadhasan should never be
compared to a modern day POET. Because even if they are capable of writing 'thathuva padalgal',
how many of the today's film industry accepts it?
I think the 'NEW WAVE' that stormed the industry
sometimes in the late 70's or early 80's (not sure!) made a transition to go from 'thathuva' to
'gramiya'+'western' taste. But the fact is VM
is extremely good in 'NOT' blending them together
and make a masala out of them. He is a definitely
'the best' among contemporary poets. But he is not
of the 'type' of our ever greatest Kannadasan.
25 years from now I would still listen to kannadasan,but I am doubtful about VM type of
- From: Anban (@ pm3-fdl05-ppp-251.tcccom.net)
on: Fri May 8 00:33:30 EDT 1998
Kumar Venkatraman i noticed you comments about my words. Thanks. If i start writing about Kannadasan by the time i complete(i doubt) there may be another VM who may claim for 'Kaviyarasu'. So i am not going to give 'Vairamuthu' title to others!!. But..i was thinking about anand's reply here..and may be we can call VM as 'Kavipputhi'. May not be meaningful in Tamil, but as he is great in Puthuk kavithai..we can not call him 'puthukavi' as he is an experienced on. So i just changed in Kalaivanar's style..so how is that
'Kavipputhi'. I would request TFM admin to find a good day to have a function and give the title
'Kavipputhi' to Mr. Diamond!!.
Muthu is rare to find..Vairam is hard to break.
But only we, TFM fans have to find it and make it fine to use it. Let us do it. Thanks.
- From: MS (@ )
on: Sun Jun 6 16:32:41 EDT 1999
This is to bring to the attention of TFM - junta + DFers the recent-expression of Kaviarasu. Let me first aplogize if I tend to disturb the posters of opposite gender. But my post intends , not to strain their faces, but to put before all the increasing obscenity in his poems. This refers to the "theendai,theendai" song.
If anybody has noticed, there is some "cheyyul" rendered (with a pathetic pronunciation) before the song . This refers to two words - "Pasalai noi" and "algul". The first one is known to many and I do not think there needs to be an explanation for this. The second word is unknown to many, I suppose. It refers to the female reproductory organ and there is "NO" other meaning. It is a "senthamizh" word for the same and is probably the worst expression by any poet. Be it senthamizh or kochchai thamizh, IMO, it is ridiculous to have such words in film lyrics.
Now that the poets are running out of creativity for finding lyrics, they either resort to "english" or "unknown senthamizh" phrases. I do not think the day is not far away when you will have the menial scatological expressions too in the lyrics. God save the lyrics !!
List all pages of this thread