Query

ILLAYARAAJA & A.R. RAHMAN JOINS HAND TOGETHER FOR KAMAL HASSAN'S NEW HOME PRODUCTION

Topic started by JPS (@ ppp45-216.lvsb.vsnl.net.in) on Thu Jul 2 09:24:42 EDT 1998.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

Responses:

From: Rajesh (@ pdxss902.jf.intel.com) on: Thu Jul 2 13:11:44 EDT 1998

Is this reliable info? If yes, what movie?
From: gatsby (@ 206.88.172.188) on: Thu Jul 2 15:58:53 EDT 1998

ore uraila rendu kathiyaa ? chance illa.
Thalivaroda Rehmana. No.
From: buddy (@ synergy.nus.edu.sg) on: Thu Jul 2 21:47:31 EDT 1998

I don't beleive this.
But I would be happy if they work,
IR creativity and ARR technology would result in great product.

Remember MSV/IR combo.
From: S.P MAHENDRAN (@ 161.139.38.86) on: Fri Jul 3 01:31:31 EDT 1998

Can you give to me which tamil movie they want to work together.Is this information are true?I would be happy to hear this if this team work really happen.
From: udaanz (@ usr2-3-dialup31.mix1.irving.mci.net) on: Sun Jul 5 02:10:52 EDT 1998

name of the movie s udaanz udaanzzzzzz
From: R.Balaji (@ 129.130.140.41) on: Sun Jul 5 11:22:27 EDT 1998

Hi JPS,
If you are giving this thread just for the sake of seeing your name here please do not do so.
If the information what you have given is true please give us soem reliable source to verify.
We would be very happy to see your response.
From: Kalanjiyam (@ proxy.qatar.net.qa) on: Sun Jul 5 14:44:41 EDT 1998

I think that movie's name is
"Kadala kadala Marudanayagathin athai enge"

It is to be directed by shankar and Yuvanshankar raja is going to do rerecording and so so..
What is happening to TFM Where are we heading yaar... Hey no body there...?

Lot of people are having 'Rasigas' please comeforward and do something create some MIDI files.
From: MOHMD.RAFI (@ 194.170.2.7) on: Sun Jul 5 17:04:06 EDT 1998

HAI FREINDS,
HERE WE ARE ANXIOUSELY DISCUSSING ABOUT THIS, BUT THEY(IR&ARR)EVEN CONSIDER ABOUT US!IF THIS WILL HAPPENS I WILL BE REALLY GLAD TO HEAR THAT.AND THAT WILL BE AN UNFORGETTABLE 'SYMPONY'
From: Veera Akkoor (@ 1cust228.tnt2.det1.da.uu.net) on: Sun Jul 5 20:27:17 EDT 1998

Could you compare IR/MSV combo with IR/ARR combo. MSV and IR had a great combo because both had mutual respect for each other. It needs magnanimity on both ends to jointly perform a success. I don't think ARR has that great a heart to join with the great maestro and give something great. IR could join with Zakir Hussain and produce effective stuff.

Always IR did a great job in combo. After MSV he did join with 5 Hungarian artists ( new instruments) and gave spellbound music in "GURU".
So I do have full confidence if Ustad and the Maestro join and help Kamal to give his dream venture a big hand.

Thanks

Veera Akkoor
From: Prakash Balakrishnan (@ spider-tp021.proxy.aol.com) on: Sun Jul 5 21:48:14 EDT 1998

I totally agree with Veera Akkoor.If MSV & IR join together then IR-ARR can join together.

But is it realy Kamal going to take Marudhanayagam??? :):):):)....

If that is true then anything possible in the world..

Hello Kamal fans... No Bricks please.. Just for fun..
From: anand (@ antarctis-ext.wise.edt.ericsson.se) on: Mon Jul 6 01:25:11 EDT 1998

Hi JPS,

Is ur news reliable. being in chennai i could not
find this news in any newspaper. Ur wasting ur time and others too.

Please give info only if it is relaible.

These types of combinations never going to take place in TFM.
From: Raghav (@ ppp36-97.bng.vsnl.net.in) on: Mon Jul 6 01:28:51 EDT 1998

I don't think Marudhanayagam will come out. But, i don't know how far this IR&ARR combo is true. Anybody can help in this regard? But for me it is very hard to accept IR & ARR combo. MSV & IR combo is totally different. Nobody can argue MSV&IR why not IR&ARR. Anyhow i need result from our TFM & Kamal fans.

Why our people don't put some tamizh MIDI files. If anybody trying to do that my hearty wishes to them. I welcome that.
From: S.P MAHENDRAN (@ 161.139.38.86) on: Tue Jul 7 01:44:25 EDT 1998

I don't think this is a true massage.JPS try to fool us.This is not good.Last sunday i read in the newspaper that in a musical night AR has put a ring in IR finger but IR put back the ring in AR finger.From here we know that IR do not like work together with AR.AR don't reach that standard.For example,another word for music is IR(music is IR and IR is music).He is god of music.So don't try to do like this again.
From: peesoo (@ horus.erlm.siemens.de) on: Tue Jul 7 04:39:12 EDT 1998

Hi All,

After reading JPS's mail, I went thru all cine-magazines, news papers, news paper supplements, cine-bits etc..

None of them doesnt even give a clue for this msg.
Looks like JPS is taking all of us back in time to April. Be aware of internet-liers!!
From: Prakash Balakrishnan (@ gate7.ca.us.ibm.com) on: Tue Jul 7 13:22:44 EDT 1998

Indha News 'udanze'-aggavE irukkattum...
En ARR- IRudan music poda kudaathu????
ARR was working under IR.

Proof:-
According the interview of 'Drums' Siva in Kumudam, (2-7-98) ARR worked with IR in 'Punnagai Mannan' during that time computer re-recording gave some trouble and they used "live play".

Why can't ARR-IR together score the music for a film?? give me proper reason..

Thalaivarukkum - ARRkkuma??? No chance blah,blah... ellam vENDam.. IR is not the authority of TFM.

His way of music is totally different from MSV, but they together scored for 3 films. If MSV-IR together score the music, then ARR-IR can score music for a film.
From: mohan. (@ gw1.cat.com) on: Tue Jul 7 13:56:33 EDT 1998

idhu unmaya irukka chance-ae illai.

both of them have contrasting thoughts as far as music is concerned. I don't think, a product out of their combination would be good.

it would be better if they stand apart and continue to provide tamil filmdom with the variety they are providing today.

dayavu seidhu indha maadiri vishayathila 'pugai' kilappadeergal...
From: peesoo (@ horus.erlm.siemens.de) on: Wed Jul 8 05:09:10 EDT 1998

Dear Prakash,

Nothing wrong in IR & ARR working together. It would be great if two of them scores for a movie.

They were so many assistants/members of IR gorup who became a MD of their own lately:

1. narashimhan
2. ARR
3. uttam singh [MD of Dil tho pAgal hi, Conductor of India 24 hours]

They way IR worked with these guys were different when they were in his team. But if he has to score music with any of these guys, the approach has to be entirly different as now they have their own "isai-kena isaindhidum rasihargal raajjiyam".

IR may have to compromise certain things in going for a combo, which we, the IR fans, dont want him to do due to the sole reason that we are extremely satisfied with his own-stylish-spontaneous score. This argument applies to ARR as well as he is equally talented artist. [I have no doubt abt this. Even after working under IR, there is no trace of IR style in his music! He could able to create his own stamp!] Too many cooks might spoil the feast!

But already the music produced by Deva Sir seems to be a concoction of IR & ARR. So we are not really looking forward for IR-ARR merger!
From: mohan (@ gw1.cat.com) on: Wed Jul 8 10:40:46 EDT 1998

SABHASH thiru PRAKASH avargale...!

sariyana badhil.... I agree with you 100%

While deva sir is already doing the job of a IR-ARR mix, we don't really need the big guys to manually do a mix by themselves.

Thani thaniya music pottathaan rendu perukkum azhagum perumaiyum....

appathaan deva sir kaattla mazhayum peyyum... :-)

deva fans, no brickbats please!

mohan.
From: mohan (@ gw1.cat.com) on: Wed Jul 8 10:42:45 EDT 1998

ooops...!

sorry thiru prakash avargale... my previous response was intended for 'peesoo'.

From: Satish (@ cs-line12.cs.umn.edu) on: Wed Jul 8 19:21:13 EDT 1998

Bringing together IR and ARR in the same movie was attempted last year by director, JAYARAJ, who won (again) the national award for best director earlier this year. Attached is an excerpt from an article in "The Week" magazine which was published in July 1997. I am not sure of the status of the film that is mentioned in this article. I think JAYARAJ won the best director award for a different film than the one mentioned in this article.



Classical notes





It is going to be a film with a difference, riding on the theme of


rain and its various moods which reflect the human condition.


At 32, ace Malayalam director Jayaraj is already a veteran with 11


films including national award-winninng Deshadanam under his belt.





The new offering is the love story of a ghazal singer (played by


Mohan Lal) and his unrequited love for a poetess who blooms too


early. The film is to be shot in Mumbai and Kerala and is very much


in tune with a genre of cinema that dares to be different.





Music will form the soul of the film and eight maestros will


compose it. There is ghazal virtuoso Hariharan, Vanraj Bhatia,


Pandit Raghunath Seth, Telugu superstar Keeravani, Raveendran,


Bhupen Hazarika, Ilayaraja and A.R. Rehman. 





Ilayaraja has agreed in


principle to compose the music for the poems that will lace the


film. Negotiations are on with Rehman to tie up the logistics.





The film will feature Malayalam superstar Mohan Lal, Suresh Gopi and TV star Mayuri.

From: Anban (@ 207.7.41.76) on: Wed Jul 8 23:45:00 EDT 1998

Anban Strikes back!!!

Athu oru pasumaiyaana gramam, vidikalaile kathiravan oli, nathu naduthal, lesa ilan katru
antha mara ilaikal valiya odumpothu iniya geetham,
kuyil arambikkirathu. Appadiye camera antha odaiyil kulinkinra kathayanagiyai closeuple kondu
varuthul. Kindal pechukalilirunthu oru iniya padal, antha kramathu pinnaniyode, Isaignani
Ilayarajavin innisaiyil. Pattu mudinchathu, apdiye oru Honda motor cyclele(US style!), antha
ilan kathanayaganode jolly ride, starts with rock music and drums beats, ARRin modern stylele oru song, so..intha nayagan India poi, antha nayakiya
parthu kathal panni kalyanam...athellam venthirayil kanga. Director : Anban, Music : IR & AR at first time combination. Producer : TFM!!.
Releasing date : 01/01/00. (Y2K problems!!).

Kanavukku kasa kodukkanum. Anupavippome..
Anbudan..Anban.
From: Raghav (@ ppp36-107.bng.vsnl.net.in) on: Thu Jul 9 02:04:59 EDT 1998

Dear Anban,

I love they way you commented. Still, I am laughing. If you become the director as you told, please give me a chance to act as that kathanayakan and kathanayagi should be Kate Winslet. Surely this pair will match your story.