Topic started by IRRRRRRR (@ 184.108.40.206) on Sat Jul 19 14:06:23 EDT 2003.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
These are my entries
2) Shankar Ganesh
None of these guys know any music so to say. Unbelievable plagiarists to boot. These guys have zero self repect and work ethics. All they know is to steal other man's hardwork and call it their own. We may or may not like Raja, Rahman, KVM, MSV, G Ramanathan. But all of them knew music and were quite original(yes odd ones excluded).
- Old responses
- From: Venky (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Wed Jul 30 07:02:45 EDT 2003
lusu, we never claimed that we can do better. We aren't trying to be md's and cheat our fans with recycled tunes. Maybe for you, the sun shines out of these crap md's as*s but it doesn't for us.
- From: Ravi (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Wed Jul 30 07:37:31 EDT 2003
LordLabakuDas, I really loved ur comments. They triggered my laughing cells as well :-))
Btw, I do agree with your and Venky's point about SAR. But I dont know why, his tunes churn out a sense of nostalgia in me - a feeling of subtle happiness, nicety esp the signature tunes of each film like Edho oru paattu, Rosappu chinna rosappu, oru devadhai vandhu vittal... I dont deny the fact that his tunes reflect his old compositions or lifted from elsewhere, I am just saying his music gives a soothing effect (LordLB, probably you might want to differ here - sorry if my view is aggravating your 'Priyamana Thozhi' kaduppu!!) ;-)
- From: VIKASH (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Wed Jul 30 08:47:01 EDT 2003
Also include Bharadwaj. His songs sucks.
- From: ? (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Wed Jul 30 09:43:48 EDT 2003
Ravi, with SAR's tunes, you not only get nostalgia, you also get nausea and deja vu. avarukku irukkarathey 3 tune. apparam nostalgia eppadi varama irukkum? :-)
- From: Ravi (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Wed Jul 30 10:38:25 EDT 2003
?, that was a good one ha! ha!
- From: Raghu (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Wed Jul 30 10:44:18 EDT 2003
Marahathamni or known as Keeravani , is an excellent composer, don't compare him with the likes of Deva / Sirpy, he may commit suicide, if he hears it :))
Bharadwaj is also an excellent composer, he/marahathamani/Vidya saagar are properly trained Carnatic artists.
- From: L (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Wed Jul 30 10:49:14 EDT 2003
Your review was very good. "Nalla MD and Nolla" MD. Couldn't stop laughing, after reading it. Keep it coming..!
- From: Musio (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Wed Jul 30 11:12:19 EDT 2003
About Bharadwaj Greatest HIt ' Oh Podu'.
I Pity TFM Industry for coming down to such a poor musical taste. Now so many other MD's have started to give such type of Songs. Eg: 'Kalakkuven Kalakkkuven', 'Arival Meesai Th0ol', 'Allu Allu', ..... & so many.
I doubt whether these Songs really pleasing to hear! Awaiting your opinion.
- From: Kavin Malar (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Thu Jul 31 02:55:53 EDT 2003
S.. Musio.. horrible to hear.. have u listened to aeroplane parakkuthu par mela.. from paarai? What an irritating one?
- From: STONE COLD (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Thu Jul 31 03:13:16 EDT 2003
There is a song by baradwaj exactly like O Podu in Kadhal Dot Com if not mistaken....
- From: Mythila (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Thu Jul 31 04:37:17 EDT 2003
LLD, waiting for your 2nd installment of which other MDs to axe
- From: Terminator 3 (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Thu Jul 31 06:25:51 EDT 2003
I would like to mention that none of the producers who gave an opportunity to these music directors were fools. Definitely without some musical knowledge, none of these guys could have entered into the field. The problem is that they are not giving something more creative from their side but depend on something for the baseline. Therefore, I would suggest this thread not to call them worst MDs.
List all pages of this thread
Back to the Forum