Topic started by Disappointed Fan (@ 188.8.131.52) on Sat Sep 20 04:24:40 EDT 2003.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
I was really impressed when Roja came out and I kept looking out for such impressive release after that. But to date, so far non of his film has any impact of Roja. There may be some good ones along the way but that I can get it from other TFM MDs. It\'s really disappointing that he has never matched any song compared to Chinna Chinna Aasai. For the last 7 years or so I keep yearning but to no avail. So many of his albums are of mediocre level. I really would like to know what caused ARR\'s downfall?
1) Trying too much in other fields and ignoring Tamil films?
2) Trying to fuse in too much western pop/rock and making listeners irritated?
3) Trying to be both Mozart and Michael Jackson of India?
4) Using so many different singers and not having any identity?
5) Again infusing too many English words to make it more hype?
6) Concentrating alot on sound quality and not giving importance to musical quality?
7) Or just limited talent?
It\'s really heart-ching to see someone I used to like go down like that.
- Old responses
- From: MUSIC MAN (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Mon Dec 29 12:13:56 EST 2003
THE QUESTION ITSELF IS KIDDING. ARR NEVER FALL DOWN. HE IS STILL NO.1 MUSIC DIRECTOR OF TAMIL AS WELL AS IN HINDI. NOBODY NEAR TO HIS COMPOSITIONS. HE IS OUTSTANDING PERFORMANCE AND HE IS PRODIGY.
- From: x (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Wed Dec 31 02:52:25 EST 2003
>>MUSIC MAN --
The best comedy of the YEAR and best COMEDIAN award should be given to u and arr jointly....hehehehe
- From: : ) (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Wed Dec 31 03:10:57 EST 2003
Oh I know I know... Arr Downfall is because... he tripped over a stone... Am i correct...? So what am i getting anyway...? Idiots get a life, startin idiotic threads... Let the dogs bark all day long... NOthing can change the fact... ARR is well - known all around the world... Woof Woof... HAHAAhhahahahahahhahaaaaaa
- From: music-man (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Wed Dec 31 04:41:32 EST 2003
Ah!! What a surprise people have started using even my name.Iam one of the rare visitors to TFM.
- From: music-man (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Wed Dec 31 04:42:44 EST 2003
I don’t think ARR copies much.If we analyse the songs of each and every MD,there are inspirations.No one can deny that IR,ARR,MSV are inspired from foreign sources.So are the MD’s of other countries .
My point is that if we see ARR songs,I can see nowhere that ARR actually lifted the tunes.Only on two or three songs the tune looked similar to some extent.
Even if we see the sites like i2fs and mail-bag.com there we can find that only the beats may be similar but the tune will be entirely different.Eg:Iruvar piano piece---The piano piece is inspired,but the tune is different.The piano piece appears for only 30 sec.
Then the beats from Indian”Telephone Mannipol”—here only the beats are similar.These things happen with the commercial loops in the free music libraries.
These cannot be termed as copy because other MD’s are actually lifting the whole tune without dignity.(Eg—YSR,Deva,Sirpy)
I don’t think ARR produces crap music.
His KV,Boys,E20U18,KKS are all excellent albums—good in musical quality than any other albums in recent times.
- From: Mahesh (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Wed Dec 31 05:47:02 EST 2003
Participate in this poll
NMCC - NanjilOnline.com Makkal Cine Choice 2003
Visit the above site to register your vote guys...
- From: Music4ever (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Wed Dec 31 11:32:23 EST 2003
"Isai varavangalukkum isai vara vecchukkaravangallukkum vitthiyasam yeppavum irukkum".
I hope the above pronouncement is not out of a sense of superiority or smugness.
As a matter of fact it is no great observation, IMO, the 'truism' transcending music and having applicability to almost all areas of human endeavour -- all humans are equal but some or more equal (in talent) than others!
Don't know how pertinent is the following observation to the discussion but still: Dravid cricket varavechurukkaravar.
- From: vs (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Thu Jan 1 01:12:16 EST 2004
the reason for his downfall is that his music is not everlasting. the songs would not last long. this is because he doesnt uses percussion instruments.
Its only a HYPE. IR is still and ever no 1.
- From: jacky (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Sun Jan 4 03:49:34 EST 2004
only IR can make everlasting tunes, IR is a musical avtar, IR wants quality in all his songs.
IR is paid unthinkable amounts to score music.
This is an IRONY or a sattire?
lol guess yourself.
- From: arr fan (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Tue Jan 6 09:31:05 EST 2004
ohh god paavam rahman
- From: C~P (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Tue Jan 6 11:06:29 EST 2004
IP-ku yaeththa post! ;-)
List all pages of this thread
Back to the Forum