Topic started by Amma (@ 202.54.43.173) on Thu Jun 11 08:50:25 EDT 1998.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

Does " chanda rey chanda rey" (sapnay) match up to the visual beauty that "vennilavey vennilavey" (minsara kanavu) evokes? For that matter are hindi lyrics of tamil dubbed movies of the same calibre as the original? Or are they better?
Anyway, how ARE they written? Does the director brief both the lyricists on the situation and let them come up with their own lyrics or does one of them write and the other transcreates ? Speculate here....

Responses:

• Old responses
  
• From: happy (@ 66.119.33.135) on: Sat Jan 4 10:56:28 EST 2003
  
  seems to be dead here ? KABRISTAN ??
  
  
• From: Nishal (@ 24.185.72.98) on: Thu Feb 13 17:32:02 EST 2003
  
  DO DIL MIL RAHE HAIN
  gup-chup gup-chup chup chup... Secretly, silently...
  do dil mil rahe hai.n magar chupke chupke... Two hearts are meeting, but quietly.
  sabko ho rahii hai haa.n sabko ho rahii hai khabar chupke chupke Everyone is noticing; yes, everyone is quietly noticing.
  do dil mil rahe hai.n magar chupke chupke Two hearts are meeting, but quietly and secretly.
  saa.nso.n me.n baRii bekaraarii Their breaths are unsteady;
  aa.nkho.n me.n ka'ii raat jage they've stayed away nights on end.
  kabhii kahii.n lag jaa'e dil to Sometimes when you fall in love,
  kahii.n phir dil na lage you aren't pleased by anything.
  apne dil me.n zaraa thaam luu.n I'll just keep hold of my heart,
  jaaduu ka mai.n ise naam duu.n since I recognize that this is magic.
  jaaduu kar rahaa hai asar chupke chupke Quietly the magic is taking effect.
  do dil mil rahe hai.n magar chupke chupke Two hearts are meeting, but quietly and secretly.
  aise bhole bankar hai baiTHe They sit so innocently,
  jaise koii baat nahii.n as if there's nothing at all going on.
  sab kuchh nazar aa rahaa hai But everything is apparent (to those around them).
  din hai yeh raat nahii.n This is broad daylight, not the dark of night.
  kya hai kuchh bhii nahii.n hai agar What is it, if it's nothing at all?
  ho.nTHo.n pe hai khaamoshi magar Their lips are silent, but...
  baate.n kar rahii hai.n nazar chupke chupke silently their glances speak to each other.
  do dil mil rahe hai.n magar chupke chupke Two hearts are meeting, but quietly and secretly.
  kahii.n aag lagne se pahale Before flames burst into life,
  uTHta hai aisa dhu'aa.n smoke like this arises.
  jaisa hai idhar ka nazaara vaisa hii udhar ka samaa And it looks just like it does right here.
  dil me.n kaisii kasak sii jagii What an ache awakes in the heart!
  dono.n jaanib baraabar lagii Both sides seem (to feel it) equally.
  dekho to idhar se udhar chupke chupke Look from one to the other, silently.
  do dil mil rahe hai.n magar chupke chupke Two hearts are meeting, but quietly.
  sabko ho rahii hai khabar chupke chupke Quietly, everyone is noticing.
  do dil mil rahe hai.n magar chupke chupke Two hearts are meeting, but quietly.
  gup-chup gup-chup chup chup... Secretly, silently...
  magar chupke chupke... But quietly...
  
  
• From: Misguided Soul (@ 61.1.43.111) on: Fri Feb 14 13:39:46 EST 2003
  
  bhen chodo...why you all are foocking us so hard..
  just get your ass..off this site and let us leave without your dirty pussys
  
  
• From: Ajay kumar (@ 61.0.176.24) on: Fri Feb 21 07:02:56 EST 2003
  
  Hello
  I wanna learn japani Language to Speak And write.
  If you know any Website and any Book then Please send mail me.
  For this work Please Help Me.
  
  
• From: Ajay kumar (@ 61.0.176.24) on: Fri Feb 21 07:03:50 EST 2003
  
  Hello
  I wanna learn Hindi To Japani Language to Speak And write.
  If you know any Website and any Book then Please send mail me.
  For this work Please Help Me.
  
  
• From: midhath (@ 202.1.201.228) on: Sat Feb 22 22:03:00 EST 2003
  
  I want to get some english translations of latest hindi songs.
  
  can any one help me in this case?
  
  if so, send me witj the following informations:
  name of the song
  film
  singers
  actors
  
  
• From: aimie (@ 202.1.201.227) on: Sat Mar 1 22:32:05 EST 2003
  
  i'd like to know the meaning of the song:
  
  Lute Koi Man Ka Nagar Ban Ke Mera Saathi
  Kaun Hai Woh, Apno Mein Kabhi, Aisa Kahin Hota Hai,
  Ye To Bada Dhokha Hai
  Lute Koi ...
  
  Yahin Pe Kahin Hai, Mere Man Ka Chor
  Nazar Pa De To Baiyan Dun Maro
  Jaane Do, Jaise Tum Pyare Ho,
  Vo Bhi Mujhe Pyara Hai, Jine Ka Sahara Hai
  Dekho Ji Tumhaari Yahi Batiyan Mujhako Hain Tadapaatin
  Lute Koi ...
  
  Rog Mere Ji Kaa, Mere Dil Kaa Chain
  Saanvala Saa Mukhada, Usape Kaare Nain
  Aise Ko, Roke Ab Kaun Bhala,
  Dil Se Jo Pyari Hai, Sajani Hamari Hai
  Ka Karun Main Bin Usake Rah Bhii Nahin Pati
  Lute Koi ...
  
  
• From: shaikh rizwan (@ 202.68.141.10) on: Wed Mar 12 02:27:37 EST 2003
  
  i want totally song of film ek dooje ke liye please give me this song
  i like this film's songs.
  
  
• From: AR Rahman Fan (@ 12.89.135.73) on: Wed May 21 14:58:35 EDT 2003
  
  as to the question; it seems to me that tamil in general has more syllables than hindi, making the overall sound of tamil better; it maintains beat better. as to translation, given that the majority of AR Rahman's hits are in tamil, the original meaning lies in tamil. The hindi remakes therefore have two options - straight translation where its the same meaning but no rhyme, rhythm, etc. or translate to rhyme, in which meaning is lost.
  
  
• From: அ.ர. ராஹமாண் fan (@ 154.5.159.176) on: Sun Feb 1 18:54:36 EST 2004
  
  Yes AR Rahman Fan. Tamil has way better rhyme and beat to it. Not even in hindi songs can they keep a good beat to songs. They have to have 2 or three different words stuck there to make it sound a bit better.!! TAMIL IS BETTER
  
  

Want to post a response?