Topic started by Udhaya (@ host16.globalcenter.net) on Sat Jun 20 14:02:54 EDT 1998.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
This topic is derived from the exciting debate that began in the "Why no female MDs?" thread. Mano and I say yes to the Patti Mandram question while Ramki came out with a No response and gave more examples to back up his claim. The key is to show evidence from TFM as facts for your contention.
- Old responses
- From: Kanchana (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Mon Jun 29 17:07:09 EDT 1998
ulai pOl kodhikkum udhayaththukku....
alai pOl pongi varum idhayaththukku....
Adhi mudhal pala kOdugaL*
pOttadhu Adavar sattamaiyyA* [*courtesy: VM]
verum vArththaikku vilai
vaippadhil vindhaiyEdhu sollumayyA
nAlum therindhavar neer
mElum nAn eduththuraiththal vizhal neer!
[pi.ku. peNmaiyai uNmaiyAip pOtRum ungaLukku en paNivAna vaNakkangaL.]
- From: Udhaya (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Tue Jun 30 14:10:20 EDT 1998
I have already made my point, but hadn't given enough examples. Here
are some more examples to reiterate my earlier claims.
The following is another example of the female seen as the
inbamaay ennai maatravaa unnaiyae vandhu ootravaa
madhu boadhai vaendumaa idhazh boadhai nalladhu
un paeraich cholgiraen adhil boadhai ulladhu
In this song, the woman sings that her body and soul are her lover's
choalikkul thaegam irukku
maaraappil manasu irukku
rendukkum uriyavan endhan kaadhalan kaadhalan
(engae purchase order?)
Adhae paadalil pennin ganniyathai maelum eduthuk koorugiraar irattai
kal, idhil iru pen kuralgal vaeru:
Kaelvi: Paavaadai kaatril parandhaal nee enna seivaai? Pala paerin
kangal padumae nee enna seivaai?
Badhil: Paavaadai kaatril parandhaal pala paerin kangal pattaal,
paavaadai kondu mugathai mooduvaen mooduvaen (aaha, enna oru idea!)
Aval varuvaala endru aengiyaa kaadhalan etharkaaga aengukiraan indru
en pallamaana ullam vellamaaga aval varuvaalaa
kannoadu naan kanda vannangal poaga
chudidhaaril moodaadha baagangal vaazhga
Innumoru kaadhalan aadharavu marundhu tharum akkaraiyudan:
ennammaa ennammaa undhan
nenjil ulla vali enna ennammaa
sollammaa sollammaa adhaith
thottuth thottuth thudaikkanum sollammaa (Chae, enna oru akkarai thambikku)
Bharathi kanda pudhumaippen kooda ithanai azhagaaga thanathu kaadhalai
en mundhaanaikkul nee vasikkalaam
evar kandaar adhai evar kandaar
maalai vandhu saerumunnae
pillai varalaam evar kandaar
aththu meera ninaikkaadhae
kuththi viduvaen evar kandaar
(Pengalin thaevaigalaiyum avargalin tharkaappin mukkiyathaiyum valiyuruthum paadal idhu endru ninaikkiraen)
- From: Tester (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Mon Jul 6 12:27:54 EDT 1998
- From: Sridhar (@ spider-te084.proxy.aol.com)
on: Mon Jul 6 13:20:18 EDT 1998
Your presentation stood apart in terms of its depth,balance & creativity. I agree totally with your point that VM is part of a chauvinistic system; as a lyricist, he has minimal control over the "content/tone/mood" set by the director.
Since I don't have your e-mail ID I'd like to say the following to you here, hope you don't mind. I've followed your DF posting for the past several months. I'm impressed with your liberated thinking,knowledge of diverse subjects such as lyrics, western classical,jazz,tamil literature,TFM history, and the patience to share these with your fellow DFers. As a Bharadhi fan and a writer myself, I see his pudhumaippenn in your progressive ideals,knowledge and gentle assertiveness. You are a class act,ma'am, and I hope we get to read more of your vibrant writings here.
One of your DF fans,
- From: Sridhar (@ spider-tp021.proxy.aol.com)
on: Mon Jul 6 18:04:20 EDT 1998
To Mrs. Kanchana: Forgot to type in my e-mail ID.
- From: Vinoth (@ )
on: Sat Jun 23 11:27:08 EDT 2001
I am strongly against the topic which is going on at present " vairamuthu as chanvenist". I like to mention something that have u ever seen vairamuthu in his books depcting girls in a ackward way. I t might have happened in films because it is for commercial purpose and mind u in some cases we have to compramise on certain things as cinema until now is not a single man show. Further even the great kannadhasan was forced to write some songs depcting females in little bit downward fashion. i can give the example of " elantha pazham" song in one of super duper movie. So it all in the game and there is no point in
- From: venksubbi (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Sat Jun 23 21:30:59 EDT 2001
Vairamuthu in his real life has been reported to beat his wife on a number of occasions...If that is tue, he is not only a chavunist but definetely someone who should not be respected
- From: Udhaya (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Mon Jun 25 13:14:56 EDT 2001
Why wake up a dead horse to show your objection? This thread went dead three years ago. And after reading your post, I don't know what your objection is.
Unless there is published proof of your claims, please don't use slander in a public forum to establish your views.
- From: venksubbi (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Mon Jun 25 17:21:40 EDT 2001
There were published reports of these incidents in tamil magazines like Kumudham and Ananda Vikatan in the late '80s (about 88-89) time period.
- From: M (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Mon Jun 25 18:20:56 EDT 2001
Read Vikatan Dated on Jan. 07, 2001. VM and His wife are best ever couple in cine field.
- From: S T S (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Mon Jun 25 23:27:03 EDT 2001
I agree with Udhaya. VM may be loud mouthed but can't agree he is chavunist. I don't like him personally but his lyrics are far better compared to the present generation poets.
If at all the songs sound chavunist, it may be because of the situation and the director should take the responsibility for that not the lyricist.
- From: G.Ragavan (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Mon Jun 25 23:56:21 EDT 2001
Yezu Manniku Mela Neeum Inpa Latchumi - This line explains well about VM.
- From: mahabs (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Tue Jun 26 01:11:32 EDT 2001
vm is just a 'ezhuththuu viyabari'. he is having all the things a customer would like to have.
he is like a fluid which acquires the shape of the container.
- From: firstname.lastname@example.org (@ )
on: Fri May 28 19:30:15 EDT 2004
I feel you should remove the article on VM doing wrong things to his wife,it is wrong to say about him. It spoils his image,he work very hard to be in his place. Thank you.
List all pages of this thread
Back to the Forum