ARR The Most Worst
Topic started by Mahibalan (@ 220.127.116.11) on Sun Jan 21 00:36:56 EST 2001.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
I thing ARR is the worst music director.
Actually he is not the Music Director.
Cutting and Otting is ARR's Policy.
People Whose doesn't know about Illayaraja's Background Music, Why Compare to Illayaraja
- Old responses
- From: lone_ranger aka cosmician (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Mon Mar 26 07:02:56 EST 2001
Such cheap mud-slingling is like mud on TFMPAGE ...please remove this as soon as you can
- From: G.Ragavan (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Mon Mar 26 07:52:55 EST 2001
Mahibalan : This is not the correct way to start a thread. There is a way to express dislikes. By noway that should hurt others.
- From: Saneguy (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Mon Mar 26 18:04:42 EST 2001
When the "MOST WORST" guy is the number one in TFM,gets two national awards in 6 years, gets 13 filmfare awards what about guys like mottai who have been kicked out of TFM?
- From: raagapriyan (@ )
on: Tue May 15 16:03:27 EDT 2001
It is pathetic to see guys/girls glorifying ARR. he is worthless to come into music world. all his pieces are "ABASWARAM"
he is polluting the atmosphere.
- From: bharath (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Wed May 16 10:30:48 EDT 2001
i agree with karthik s. this is probably the funniest thread going around. people just venting out their vayatherichals on ARR. i thought after a decade of failiure IR fans wud keep quite but then..numbers dont have nmuch sense to them...
from their posting i guess grammer is'nt their key point....but music knowledge seem to be more absent than the grammer...
ennathaan vellai karana pazhi vanganumnaalum ippadi kolai panna thevai illai... brutall.. ithukku tamil type pannalam
- From: bm (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Wed May 16 17:24:22 EDT 2001
bharath ...i think karthik should rank these fun threads on weekly basis ...!!
- From: arr should go back to kindergarten (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Wed May 16 18:43:25 EDT 2001
i did not notice this thread. please keep it going. i think folks like anonymous is doing a great job. thanks also to mahibalan. it is a thrill to know we are all united in this issue, a matter of deep concern to all of music.
- From: gunda (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Wed May 16 22:47:05 EDT 2001
which grammar spells grammar as grammer ?
- From: S.P MAHENDRAN (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Wed May 16 23:03:57 EDT 2001
Isai therincayan Yellam Isai Gnani agida mudiyathu.
- From: mahabs (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Thu May 17 13:22:32 EDT 2001
what has grammar to do with it. english knowledge doesn't make a person's opinion right. the 'great' arr's fans also commit many grammar mistakes. even arr and ir's english is not good.
i accept that one should not throw mud on anyone. but healthy criticism should be welcomed.
>? this is your view. in this decade he has scored many outstanding albums. mogamul, bharathy, siraichaalai, guru and a lot. the failure is on the part of tamilians who couldn't recognise them. he was awarded state awards from kerala year after year for bgm and songs.
- From: bharath (@ 188.8.131.52) on: Thu May 17 14:25:36 EDT 2001
that was a typo! and If u still think it wasnt plz take a look at the posting made b4 me and u'll know what u r talking abt
"what has grammar to do with it. english knowledge doesn't make a person's opinion right. the 'great' arr's fans also commit many grammar mistakes. even arr and ir's english is not good"
yes u r right!! it has nothing to do with music. I dont recall anyone saying it had something to do!!!
"this is your view. in this decade he has scored many outstanding albums. mogamul, bharathy, siraichaalai, guru and a lot."
mogamul = above average
siraichalai = BGM excellent, songs average
bharathi = excellent
u left our kadalukku mariyadai!!
so glad u cud count the hits!!! that really means a lot :-) ... huh! u need good ppl to work with man! to give hits! ARR has good hits. sadly IR has to play it alone....
"the failure is on the part of tamilians who couldn't recognise them."
The "tamilians" that u r talking about should be those abstracted group of people that dont include u. Those people, according to u, should be uneducated mass, with little or no music knowledge. And you should really feel sorry for those pitiable people who r missing out on a great deal right!!!
plzz the tamil people whom u accept to have rejected IR's music are average people like u. IR just stopped appealing to them thats all.
"Popularity and sales, as a reflection of quality is often underestimated. Its not an exception to the rule, but the rule itself"
" he was awarded state awards from kerala year
after year for bgm and songs"
like this actress suvalaxmi or kousalya saying they arent doing tamil movies because they r busy in telugu...very credible... it so heartwarming to see a IR fan like you, yourself... decimate him...
- From: kiru (@ 184.108.40.206) on: Thu May 17 14:54:54 EDT 2001
Talking about the judgement of Tamil people, music or otherwise, I am really disappointed in the last few days ..you know why :(
- From: rajaG (@ 220.127.116.11) on: Thu May 17 18:26:34 EDT 2001
kiru: neenga Stalin kkaaga theekkuLikkap pOgiradhaa pEsikkaraangaLEy, uNmaiyaa?:-)
- From: kiru (@ 18.104.22.168) on: Thu May 17 19:25:40 EDT 2001
..I will be saved by my fans and then I will ask for MP ticket from MK, if not I will join AIADMK :) (Pathetic state of affairs in TN politics !!)
- From: guru (@ 22.214.171.124) on: Thu May 17 21:57:28 EDT 2001
from music to politics..
- From: arrfan (@ ) on: Wed Jun 13 01:20:46 EDT 2001
why has this thread NOT been closed
- From: ~~arochordidae~~ (@ 126.96.36.199) on: Wed Jun 13 19:43:44 EDT 2001
darn i'm not living in India. Politics seems to weave into every corner...hehe. No offense to ya
guys/gals..India is cool but its that political circle that irritates me. Alright, enough of the politics talk. Lets talk music, thats what we're here for:)
"Vision without action is a day-dream. Action without vision is a nightmare"
- From: Sangeeth (@ 188.8.131.52) on: Wed Jun 13 21:25:46 EDT 2001
arrfan in this forum any thread against ARR will not be closed. Better learn to live with it
- From: hari (@ 184.108.40.206) on: Wed Jun 13 23:42:16 EDT 2001
Sangeeth, please relax,
In the 2 odd years I have been surfing here, I havent seen a single thread being closed subjectively.. only "totally duplicated" threads have been closed, and the link provided to the relevant original thread.
Please dont trash the good people whose hard work has gone into the making of such a good site/DF/dhooL etc.
On the other hand, maybe this is a good opportunity to explore ideas to regulate TFM DF further. Somebody cud start a thread on this...
- From: LV (@ 220.127.116.11) on: Thu Jun 14 00:12:06 EDT 2001
1)Please close this awful thread IMMEDIATELY. IMMEDIATELY!!!!!! We all agree that IR is great -no doubt - but trashing ARR like this is a heinous crime.
2)The person who started this and those who support him must be tone deaf.
3)Maestros like Vishwa Mohan Bhatt, Hariprasad Chaursaia, Andrew Lloyd Weber, SPB, Shivkumar Sharma, Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan have all worked with ARR and praised his compositions. These people know the 'sa re ga ma pa dha ni sa' of music, and is that the reason that they all like ARR. Definitely so!!!
4)ARRs music is not restricted to the South of India, or for that matter even only India .He has reached tremendous heights and is a universally admired composer.
5)His style of orchestration is RICH and his core tunes are excellent TOO.
6)Have u heard his Lagaan. A person who does not know Hindi or Gujrathi, has given such a beautiful Gujrathi folk based tune - radha kaise na jale.
7)And the person whom u are terming 'the most worst' has won TWO national awards in just 5-6 years. And how many filmfare awards - 15??? And what a rage all his albums have been. Is there even ONE album of his thats not good? No. He is genius. He's one of THE best.
8)EVERY singer who has worked with him, praise him a lot. Are they all MAD????
9)And listen to the interludes in the songs of his Vande Mataram album. He has given a new dimension to TFM and todays rather barren HFM. Also he has become a symbol of national integration off late. Why do u think he won the Padmashri at such a young age?
10)and all those fools who are calling ARR a music EDITOR or XEROX MACHINE, u are all stupid and have a pathetic music sense. ARRs core tunes besides the orchestration etc are all HEAVENLY. see Roja.
so stop this thread and even DELETE it. We are not here to hurt anyone,mahibalan, and definitely not throw mud on such a brilliant man.
- From: yaaro (@ 18.104.22.168) on: Thu Jun 14 02:07:55 EDT 2001
points accepted-cool down.just because a thread's title says arr is worst he is not.after all this is a democracy.:-)
- From: Senthil (@ 22.214.171.124) on: Thu Jun 14 04:00:22 EDT 2001
ARR is best music director forever.
- From: mathureshan (@ 126.96.36.199) on: Thu Jun 14 07:52:06 EDT 2001
it is correct arr is not a md,just ulta
- From: hari (@ 188.8.131.52) on: Thu Jun 14 22:02:31 EDT 2001
admin... janatha are accusing u of bias... indha thread-ayum close paNNeedunga, illa.... thee kuLippOm.
- From: bb (@ 184.108.40.206) on: Fri Jun 15 13:57:16 EDT 2001
thee ellaam kuLikkaadheenga, ErkanavE veyil jaasthi:)
- From: bharath (@ 220.127.116.11) on: Thu May 17 14:25:36 EDT 2001
List all pages of this thread